Showing posts with label Alternate Rapenzel. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Alternate Rapenzel. Show all posts

Tuesday, June 19, 2018

Rapunzel's Revenge



Rapunzel's Revengeis an alternate retelling of the Rapunzel story told in a graphic novel format.

The authors chose a western setting to provide a more natural transition for Rapunzel from being a princess in need of a prince to rescue her into a strong female character who eventually meets and works with an equally strong male partner. I know many authors are trying to rewrite fairy tale female roles into stronger more independent characters.

However, what I appreciated about this version is that they did that with allowing the male role to be an equal partner, which is what people have been pushing for in women's roles in these stories. They didn't just flip the roles making the woman the strong character and the male a weak incompetent or useless character in order to make the comparison an easier one. It took more effort to write the characters as having different strengths, but as equal partners, but it made for a stronger book.

The story begins with more background than we find in the traditional tale of Rapunzel. That makes sense as this is a longer graphic novel and thus we have more time to learn about the characters. In this version we begin with a preteen Rapunzel living in a villa with Gothel, whom she believes is her mother. However, she is beginning to have flashbacks of a different life and another family. She longs to see what lies beyond the villa walls, but is forbidden to go there. As with all fairy tales, we know if it is forbidden she will be headed off to seek it.

Gothel however, didn't gain the power she has by being foolish. She knows the girl will at some point seek freedom and when she refuses her offer to join her freely and Rapunzel attempts an escape we finally see the tower of the original tale. As a resourceful girl, Rapunzel begins to find ways to utilize her long hair and it becomes and effective tool and weapon, eventually using it as her means of escape. It is at this point the story introduces and dismisses the western version of her prince. Rapunzel does not need a Prince to help her escape and he is afraid of Gothel. They part ways and she heads off to find her mother who she remembers was working in Gothel's mines.

Along her journey, she does meet a more suitable companion, Jack of Jack and the Bean Stalk fame. He too is on a quest to help his mother. They each have different talents that make this relationship a strong one allowing them to help others as they travel on their journey to rescue Rapunzel's mother and defeat Gothel. Jack's story is saved for the sequel Calamity Jack where Rapunzel has agreed to repay Jack for his assistance by helping him solve his problem.

This was a creative retelling of the Rapuzel story that finally puts Rapunzel at a place of strength and stops her from being manipulated by others. The mash up of Rapunzel and Jack and the Bean Stalk is an interesting one. If I'd been asked about what story to mash up with Rapunzel I'm not sure I'd have chosen Jack, but with the move to the Western theme it works. I also love the way they've moved the hair from being about beauty to a valuable lethal weapon and tool for Rapunzel. I'm looking forward to reviewing the sequel to see if the balance in the character's roles remains when the plot moves to Jack's world.

Monday, September 10, 2012

Terrible Tales




Terrible Tales: The Absolutely, Positively, 100 Percent TRUE Stories of Cinderella, Little Red Riding Hood, Those Three Greedy Pigs, Hairy Rapunzel, ... and Gretel as Told at the Beginning of Time is a humerous retelling of the listed tales.

In a forward, the "author" Sir Jasper Gowlings explains how he is compelled by elfin law to share the stories given to him by Feliccitatus Miserius.

As someone who enjoys alternate fairy tales I was surprised at the convincing case they made for Cinderella being mean and the story not getting out because the Prince was equally horrid and people were glad they found each other to torture. The anarchist three pigs were original. I have seen a variety of defenses made for the wolves, but that was a new one for me. Hansel and Gretel provide a very new twist on the old tale. I thought Red Riding Hood and Rapunzel were the weakest of the tales.

My suggestion with all these kinds of stories is preview before using with children. Everyone is different in what evaluating what material is comfortable for use with children. These stories are definitely focused on an older age group than normally read folk tales. I plan on picking up a copy of this book as a gift, but these books are not quite as child friendly as some of the other alternate fairy tales I have reviewed.